Talking Shorts

Talking Shorts

log in sign up
  • Films
  • Reads
  • Talks
  • Festivals
  • New Critics & New Audiences Award
  • About
  • Team
  • Support Us
  • Contributions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Imprint
  • The END
Talking Shortstalkingshorts.com

Reframing the Framer
A Lack of Clarity

Review by Leonardo Govoni
published in Films, Now Showing
published on 10.01.2023
Share   facebook linkedIn link

A found footage reflection on digital surveillance technologies that asks its viewers to connect its images to what lies at the core of the society we inhabit.

A Lack of Clarity
A Lack of Clarity
Title
A Lack of Clarity
Length
23'
Year
2020
Country
Denmark
Genre
Essay
Category
Documentary, Experimental
Director
Stefan Kruse Jørgensen
Sound
Asbjørn Derdau
Composer
Asbjørn Derdau
Festivals
Internationale Kurzfilmtage Winterthur 2020, Glasgow Short Film Festival 2021, Go Short – International Short Film Festival Nijmegen 2021, Vienna Shorts 2021, Filmfest Dresden 2021, FeKK Ljubljana Short Film Festival 2021, Short Waves Festival 2021, Festival du nouveau cinéma (FNC) 2021
This Is Short
Watch now on This Is Short.

Las Vegas. Sin City. A place that has come to represent the nest of contemporary capitalism, the pinnacle of neoliberal practices. Built as a place to be consumed and immediately left rather than to be lived, Las Vegas is a city where consumerism is celebrated and lionised at the expense of anything else. Its buildings, streets, and corners mimic those of other cities, giving life to a postmodern space that echoes the real and in which the hegemony of the market reigns over anything else. In this endless flow of glittering materialist excess in which spending money is the only given possibility, there is no room left for thinking, pausing, or even sleeping. Caught in this perpetual capitalist turbine, how often do we reflect upon what we are leaving behind and sacrificing despite this roller coaster of vacuity and entertainment?

By rearranging found footage material recorded through thermal cameras placed in Las Vegas, Stefan Kruse Jørgensen’s A Lack of Clarity stimulates a reflection regarding digital surveillance technologies’ progress, expansion, and implications. In its nature, this experimental, essayistic, documentary work reframes recorded (or even stolen) images of us to unveil how controlling mechanisms have become so embedded into contemporary society while remaining almost invisible. It asks its viewers to connect those surveillance images to what lies at the core of the society we have been shaping and inhabiting.

From its first beats—through its images, pacing, texts, and intimate voice-over—A Lack of Clarity establishes an ongoing personal dialogue with its spectators, trying to depict a portrayal beyond the mere surface, yet, before speaking to the spectator, the filmmaker speaks to himself. Those images captured by thermal cameras erase any distinction between light and dark, day and night, and they metaphorically connect to the state of sleeplessness, characterising the modern human condition and, more specifically, the filmmaker’s own. Watching those grey images and how they destroy any relation with time perception, Jørgensen seems to be drawn into the same endless sleepless nights that increasingly have become part of his routine and ours. As his sound-distorted ruminations whisper into my ears, I ask myself if this overly connected society has transformed sleeping and absence into a sin.

What is left is an endless dream-like state in which we flow around unconsciously, but the privacy barriers have become almost entirely blurred. In those new and artificial dreamy and sleepless spaces, each movement is tracked, each body temperature is scanned, and each face is recognised for consumption. In this matrix of surveillance, we cease to be humans. From figures made of flesh and blood, we turn into tendencies, parameters, and numbers that can be analysed, exploited, and consumed. Sleeping then becomes a sin precisely because it represents the last terrain companies have no access to. Yet, by always remaining in the background, Las Vegas reminds us that even this last sin can be redeemed, even sleep can be erased, and total control can lastly take place.

A Lack of Clarity goes beyond unveiling and questioning all this. The unique cinematic experience crafted by Stefan Kruse Jørgensen is so layered that the spectator is constantly triggered and never annoyed. The film immerses us into experiencing and feeling the state of blindness and confusion by which we are surrounded and towards which we have somehow lost clear sight. Through its slow-paced editing and a sonic landscape made of drone electronic pulses, the film is turned into a means for awakening us. It shakes us from a state of dizziness to shed light on the invisible and imperceptible images that inhabit our everyday lives. It faces us with the ubiquitous images of control that the simultaneous progress of digital technology and surveillance practices have injected into the modern urban landscape.

But this obsession with surveillance is not something new. As the film points out, this fetishism traces back to older centuries, to the moment in which cities started to be artificially illuminated. This longstanding tradition has led to accepting dichotomies that we should theoretically assume as incompatible, making them so embedded within us that we stopped questioning them. Being monitored, framed, observed, scanned, and surveilled does not feel like something imposed, nor as something invasive to our privacies because we have been told those practices serve something more critical: protect us. But protect us from what?

In and through the often blurred and slow-paced images of A Lack of Clarity, we have come to question whether there’s any perceived distinction left between security and terror, control and freedom, and dictatorship and liberty. But even more, what is the line between all those almost incompatible concepts? Who does trace this line? And for what sake?

This text was developed during the Film Criticism Workshop at Filmfest Dresden in July 2021, with the kind support of International Visegrad Fund, Deutsch-Tschechischer Zukunftsfonds and Landesdirektion Sachsen.

 
Logo: Sachsen
 
Logo: Visegrad Fund
 
Logo: Deutsch-Tschechischer Zukunftsfonds

Mentioned Films

Footnotes

Text by

Leonardo Govoni.

Leonardo Govoni is an Italian film and video producer based in Tallinn, Estonia, whose cinematic writings explore the interactions and intersections between film forms, aesthetics, and philosophy.

More

Comments

There are no comments yet, be the first!

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Related

Films On The Circuit

Sit. Play. Stay.

The Leash of Love

Review by Ilo Tuule Rajand

Reflecting on the lives of dogs, Cecilie Flyger Hansen unlocks the true crux of their relationship with humans: affection can coexist with domination.

Films On The Circuit

A Study of Empathy

Scratching the Surface

Review by Claudius Kesseböhmer

All the markers of artfulness seem to be in place, and yet this self-proclaimed study of empathy quickly wears thin.

Nest
Films Archive

Nest

Carved in Time

Review by Niv Fux

In a clever and playful moral, the extensive process of constructing a tree house charts the significance of time.

Reframing the Framer — Talking Shorts

Support us

Consider a donation!
Donate

Stay updated
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Thank you!
Your subscription to our list has been confirmed.

Short films are key to cinematic innovation. Because of their brevity, they allow filmmakers to react to the world around them more instinctively and showcase a stunning range of artistic expressions. As a magazine dedicated to short films, Talking Shorts aims to create a wider discourse about this often-overlooked art form.

We strive to produce universally readable content that can inspire, cultivate, and educate a broad range of audiences, from students and scholars to non-cinephile readers, in an attempt to connect filmmakers, audiences, festival organisers, and a young generation of film lovers who might not yet know what short films are or can do.

Since 2023, Talking Shorts is the official outlet of The European Network for Film Discourse (The END), which consists of 8 unique and diverse European film festivals and is funded by the Creative Europe MEDIA Programme of the European Union. Our work and publications are closely connected to the (European) film festival landscape.

Supported by 
Logo: Creative Europe MEDIA
Family Festivals 
Logo: FeKK – Ljubljana Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Filmfest Dresden
 
Logo: Kurzfilm Festival Hamburg
 
Logo: London Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Vienna Shorts
Partner Festivals 
Logo: Clermont-Ferrand International Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Concorto Film Festival
 
Logo: Dokufest
 
Logo: Drama International Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Festival du nouveau cinéma (FNC)
 
Logo: Festival Regard
 
Logo: Glasgow Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Go Short — International Short Film Festival Nijmegen
 
Logo: Internationale Kurzfilmtage Winterthur
 
Logo: Leuven International Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Minimalen Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Vilnius Short Film Festival
 
Logo: XPOSED Queer Film Festival Berlin
Supporting Festivals 
Logo: Bucharest International Experimental Film Festival
 
Logo: Curtas Vila do Conde
 
Logo: IDFA
 
Logo: Lago Film Fest
 
Logo: Leiden Shorts
 
Logo: Lviv International Short Film Festival Wiz-Art
 
Logo: Tampere Film Festival
 
Logo: Uppsala Short Film Festival
Content Partners 
Logo: Kortfilm.be
 
Logo: This Is Short
Industry Collaborators 
Logo: The Short Film Lab
 
Logo: SFC Rendez-vous Industry Festival de Cannes
We are using cookies for analytics purposes.
See our Privacy Policy