Talking Shorts

Talking Shorts

log in sign up
  • Films
  • Reads
  • Talks
  • Festivals
  • New Critics & New Audiences Award
  • About
  • Team
  • Support Us
  • Contributions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Imprint
  • The END
Talking Shortstalkingshorts.com

Spheres Of Consciousness
Square the Circle

Review by Anas Sareen
published in Films, On The Circuit
published on 07.02.2024
Share   facebook linkedIn link

With an unpretentious approach to existential questions, Finnish filmmaker Hanna Hovitie offers a perfect example of what humility can do in art.

Square the Circle
Square the Circle
Title
Square the Circle
Original title
Ympyrän neliöimisestä
Year
2023
Length
17'
Country
Finland
Genre
Essay, Portrait
Category
Documentary, Experimental
Director
Hanna Hovitie
Screenplay
Hanna Hovitie
Cast
Hanna Hovitie
Producer
Laura Kangasniemi
Production company
Playart Productions
Cinematography
Hanna Hovitie
Editor
Hanna Hovitie
Sound
Roope Mantere
Distributor
Playart Productions
Festivals
International Film Festival Rotterdam 2023, Tampere Film Festival 2023, Krakow Film Festival 2023, Vancouver International Film Festival 2023 , Vienna Shorts 2023, Leuven International Short Film Festival 2023, Beijing International Short Film Festival 2023, Minimalen Short Film Festival 2024

Like a rolling marble that catches your eye, Hanna Hovitie’s film is a world onto its own. Formally ingenious, Square the Circle is a journey of poetic introspection that develops its own simple yet singular language. A marvel of thoughtfulness, the film’s quiet power outlasts each viewing.

Against much of contemporary essayistic cinema that loses itself in rambling narcissism, Hovitie’s soul-searching is couched in a humble and humorous first-person: the film spins on the axis of a female voice, as its maker ponders existential dilemmas in soft-paced Finnish. Hovitie is here a director, narrator, and lead character, her confessional commentary the verbal counterpart to a wandering body engaged in the meditative survey of snowy expanses, runs through fields, and stargazing.

Set into motion with a bit of motherly advice, the film opens with an intertitle that immediately elicits a smile: “‘Surely you’ll find your place.’ – Mom” Hanna’s quest begins, and ruminations on belonging and purpose come to us in analogies borrowed from elementary principles of geometry and mathematics. Yet mathematics is an infinite subject and our director-poet is quickly overwhelmed by the scope of her problems. Two-dimensional animations appear, drawn by an invisible hand on what looks like a chalk blackboard, and when a simple circle morphs into a revolving sphere, we understand that the circle, like the self, is haunted by the abyss of infinite time and space. Hanna issues her own diagnosis: she suffers from “space anxiety,” a form of nausea that arises from her inability to contemplate the infinite.

Damn, girl. To the rest of us, the self is an equation hard enough to solve without the added weight of such metaphysical considerations. Only, this is part of the film’s comic conceit: minor anxieties are blown up into cosmic-sized problems before these are punctured with aphoristic asides.

The seasons provide Hovitie’s inner journey with a convenient metaphorical architecture: long days of Nordic darkness become the expression of an anxious soul while the sun’s return provides scenes of emotional respite. Yet the fears she voices are not simply the outcome of Nordic geography or weather. At times, Hovitie seems to speak for an entire generation, weary of the punishing tempo of twenty-first-century life: “I’m a slow person,” she tells us, “I need an eternity just to eat a sandwich.” And levity works best to keep existential angst in check: “I’ll peak when I’m a granny,” she affirms, as evocative electronic music chimes in, elevating the thought into the promise of future geriatric bliss.

In a move as canny as it is simple, the framing device throughout is a circular cache, its rotundity magnified by a strong fisheye lens. Landscapes and figures are reconfigured to suit its radius and its metaphorical value moves playfully, from an iris, to a bubble, to the whole of our blue-green planet. Even the subtitles obey to its gravity, a constant smile of thought under the orb that is the image.

Square the Circle

Square the Circle

Renaissance artists made much of spheres and circles: Leonardo’s Salvator Mundi (1499-1510) has Christ calmly holding the entire cosmos within five barely outstretched fingers, while the limbs of Da Vinci’s Vitruvian Man are gingerly stretched out to touch both square and enclosing circle. For these male artists, these geometrical forms were ideal illustrations of the spiritual and moral perfection we were to strive for. Hovitie draws a different picture. Hers is a secular perfection and one that tends towards the paradoxical: she is, she confesses, a “procrastinating perfectionist,” who finds beauty in the flawed and the imperfect.

The lyricism of her earthly wanderings conveys this too, her voice rising amid an ever-evolving natural landscape. In that, the tone she strikes is reminiscent of American Transcendentalists like Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry Thoreau. In “Nature,” Emerson presented his poetic endeavour as such: “I am a transparent eyeball / I am nothing / I see all.” Hovitie’s ego is not as expansive, nor is her dissolution of the self so complete, while the business of being an all-encompassing eye she deftly leaves to the camera.

After standing still to contemplate the nature of Time, she resumes her journey, and the world begins to turn in lockstep, a giant hamster-wheel of grass, pines, and sky above her. But it spins so fast she has to run and tumbles into the tall grass. Only there is no loss of dignity here, no sense of shame; she is just another small human, seeking meaning and purpose on the great big ball that is the world.

A final instance of this vulnerability comes when Hanna’s solitude is suspended long enough to welcome the film’s only other character: an elder passerby laden with grocery bags. He walks up to her and peers into the camera, his face and body distorted by the lens: “Aha, what are you doing here?” he asks, “I’m not sure,” comes the reply. The man walks away, leaving our poet to stand alone on the hard round earth. Such gentle inquiries and hesitations are integral to the film’s beauty, held together by a confessional mode that reminds us that soul-searching need not be a melancholy or complacent affair.

With her unpretentious approach to existential questions, Hanna Hovitie offers a perfect example of what humility can do in art: here is poetry of the cyclical, the circular, and the spherical that manages to avoid the solipsistic. This is a feat in itself, but it is all superseded by something rarer still: when it comes to grace, consider the circle squared.

Mentioned Films

Footnotes

Text by

Anas Sareen.

After studies in literature and film history, Anas worked as a screenwriter before moving onto directing. He is a programmer for the Berlinale (Generation) and has just completed his second short film, The Gods.

More

Comments

There are no comments yet, be the first!

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Related

Loading Love
Films On The Circuit

Loading Love

Second Chances

Review by Jan Tracz

In this Finnish sci-fi love story, Ingmar Bergman’s Scenes from a Marriage meets Philip K. Dick’s philosophies on the existence of android souls.

Films Archive

The Human Torch

Cracks In The Pavement

Review by Jason Todd

There is something in these characters that writer-director Risto-Pekka Blom feels compelled to denounce and it soon becomes evident who his real targets are.

Films Archive

The Killing of Čáhcerávga

The Spell of Disorientation

Review by Jue Yang

The Killing of Čáhcerávga is not one, but five films. Each a manifesto, these films—like chapters in a book—form a cross-section of questions and statements on indigeneity, otherness, and longing.

Spheres Of Consciousness — Talking Shorts

Support us

Consider a donation!
Donate

Stay updated
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Thank you!
Your subscription to our list has been confirmed.

Short films are key to cinematic innovation. Because of their brevity, they allow filmmakers to react to the world around them more instinctively and showcase a stunning range of artistic expressions. As a magazine dedicated to short films, Talking Shorts aims to create a wider discourse about this often-overlooked art form.

We strive to produce universally readable content that can inspire, cultivate, and educate a broad range of audiences, from students and scholars to non-cinephile readers, in an attempt to connect filmmakers, audiences, festival organisers, and a young generation of film lovers who might not yet know what short films are or can do.

Since 2023, Talking Shorts is the official outlet of The European Network for Film Discourse (The END), which consists of 8 unique and diverse European film festivals and is funded by the Creative Europe MEDIA Programme of the European Union. Our work and publications are closely connected to the (European) film festival landscape.

Supported by 
Logo: Creative Europe MEDIA
Family Festivals 
Logo: FeKK – Ljubljana Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Filmfest Dresden
 
Logo: Kurzfilm Festival Hamburg
 
Logo: London Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Vienna Shorts
Partner Festivals 
Logo: Clermont-Ferrand International Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Concorto Film Festival
 
Logo: Dokufest
 
Logo: Drama International Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Festival du nouveau cinéma (FNC)
 
Logo: Festival Regard
 
Logo: Glasgow Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Go Short — International Short Film Festival Nijmegen
 
Logo: Internationale Kurzfilmtage Winterthur
 
Logo: Leuven International Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Minimalen Short Film Festival
 
Logo: Vilnius Short Film Festival
 
Logo: XPOSED Queer Film Festival Berlin
Supporting Festivals 
Logo: Bucharest International Experimental Film Festival
 
Logo: Curtas Vila do Conde
 
Logo: IDFA
 
Logo: Lago Film Fest
 
Logo: Leiden Shorts
 
Logo: Lviv International Short Film Festival Wiz-Art
 
Logo: Tampere Film Festival
 
Logo: Uppsala Short Film Festival
Content Partners 
Logo: Kortfilm.be
 
Logo: This Is Short
Industry Collaborators 
Logo: The Short Film Lab
 
Logo: SFC Rendez-vous Industry Festival de Cannes
We are using cookies for analytics purposes.
See our Privacy Policy